root/werkzeuge
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
main
werkzeuge/teamleader_test/archive/review-2025-12-04/REVIEW_INDEX.md
root cb073786b3 Initial commit: Werkzeuge-Sammlung 
Enthält:
- rdp_client.py: RDP Client mit GUI und Monitor-Auswahl
- rdp.sh: Bash-basierter RDP Client
- teamleader_test/: Network Scanner Fullstack-App
- teamleader_test2/: Network Mapper CLI

Subdirectories mit eigenem Repo wurden ausgeschlossen.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-01-28 09:39:24 +01:00

11 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Network Scanner Review - Issue Index

Quick Navigation

🔴 CRITICAL ISSUES (22 total)

🟡 WARNINGS (28 total)

🟢 IMPROVEMENTS (15 total)

CRITICAL ISSUES

Backend Critical

# Issue File Severity Status
1.2 Database session leaks in background tasks app/api/endpoints/scans.py:33-41 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.4 WebSocket not connected to scan execution app/services/scan_service.py BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.5 No error handling for empty scan results app/scanner/network_scanner.py:88-95 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.7 Invalid port range parsing crashes app/scanner/port_scanner.py:143-157 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.8 Thread-unsafe WebSocket connection manager app/api/endpoints/websocket.py:20-33 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.9 Active scans dict never cleaned up app/services/scan_service.py:20 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.10 No check for OS detection privilege requirements app/scanner/nmap_scanner.py:84 BLOCKER ⚠️ SHOULD FIX

Frontend Critical

# Issue File Severity Status
1.11 Missing Service model fields frontend/src/types/api.ts:12-23 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.12 Host status type mismatch frontend/src/types/api.ts:5-11 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.13 Topology neighbors endpoint type error frontend/src/services/api.ts:76 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.14 Scan field name mismatch frontend/src/types/api.ts:27 BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.15 Dependencies not installed frontend/package.json BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX
1.16 Frontend env vars not defined frontend/src/services/api.ts BLOCKER ❌ MUST FIX

Common Critical

# Issue File Severity Status
1.17 No input validation on network range app/scanner/network_scanner.py:55 BLOCKER ⚠️ SHOULD FIX
1.18 No rate limiting on endpoints app/api/endpoints/scans.py SECURITY ❌ MUST FIX
1.19 No authentication/authorization main.py, all endpoints SECURITY ❌ MUST FIX
1.20 Database file permissions not set app/database.py SECURITY ⚠️ SHOULD FIX
1.21 Subprocess command injection risk app/scanner/network_scanner.py:173-181 SECURITY ⚠️ SAFE BUT CHECK
1.22 No security logging All modules SECURITY ⚠️ SHOULD FIX

WARNINGS

Backend Warnings

# Issue File Line Priority
2.1 Hostname resolution could hang app/scanner/network_scanner.py 191 Medium
2.2 Banner grabbing timeout not set app/scanner/service_detector.py 50-61 Medium
2.3 Nmap parsing missing edge cases app/scanner/nmap_scanner.py 80-110 Medium
2.4 Connection detection too simplistic app/services/scan_service.py 275-315 Low
2.5 Topology generation could timeout app/services/topology_service.py 43-60 Medium
2.6 Port lists hardcoded not configurable app/scanner/network_scanner.py 20 Low
2.7 Scan type validation incomplete app/schemas.py 8-11 Low
2.8 No check for conflicting concurrent scans app/services/scan_service.py - Medium
2.9 WebSocket message size not limited app/api/endpoints/websocket.py - Medium
2.10 Async context issues in callbacks app/services/scan_service.py 302-322 Medium

Frontend Warnings

# Issue File Line Priority
2.11 API error handling incomplete frontend/src/services/api.ts - Medium
2.12 WebSocket reconnection could be better frontend/src/services/websocket.ts 65-75 Low
2.13 Unused imports not caught Multiple files - Low
2.14 Missing PropTypes validation All React components - Low
2.15 No rate limit error feedback Frontend services - Low

Security & Database Warnings

# Issue File Category Priority
2.16 No database migrations app/database.py DB High
2.17 SQLite not production-ready app/config.py DB High
2.18 No backup strategy - DB High
2.19 CORS too permissive main.py:41-46 Security High
2.20 No HTTPS enforcement main.py Security High
2.21 Missing security headers main.py Security High
2.22 Debug mode enabled by default .env.example:8 Security High
2.23 No secrets management - Security High
2.24 No CSRF protection main.py Security High
2.25 Subprocess calls error handling app/scanner/network_scanner.py:173 Security Medium
2.26 Custom ports not validated app/schemas.py Validation Medium
2.27 No request size limiting main.py Security Medium
2.28 Logs may contain sensitive data All modules Security Low

IMPROVEMENTS

Code Quality (3.1-3.5)

# Issue Current Recommended Effort
3.1 Docstrings incomplete Partial Complete with examples 2hrs
3.2 Type hints missing ~80% 100% with mypy strict 3hrs
3.3 Magic numbers scattered Various Extract to constants 1hr
3.4 Config not structured Strings Dataclasses/enums 2hrs
3.5 Separation of concerns Mixed Better module division 3hrs

Testing (3.6-3.10)

# Issue Current Recommended Effort
3.6 Unit tests Basic Comprehensive scanner tests 4hrs
3.7 Integration tests None API integration suite 4hrs
3.8 E2E tests None Full workflow tests 6hrs
3.9 Performance tests None Load testing suite 3hrs
3.10 Security tests None OWASP/security tests 4hrs

Documentation (3.11-3.15)

# Issue Current Recommended Effort
3.11 API docs Auto-generated Add examples 2hrs
3.12 Architecture docs Text only Add diagrams 2hrs
3.13 Troubleshooting Basic Comprehensive guide 3hrs
3.14 Performance tuning None Optimization guide 2hrs
3.15 Deployment None Docker/K8s guides 4hrs

ISSUE STATISTICS

By Severity

🔴 CRITICAL:      22 issues
   - BLOCKERS:    8 issues (must fix to run)
   - SECURITY:    6 issues (enable production use)
   - OTHER:       8 issues (important fixes)

🟡 WARNING:       28 issues
   - HIGH:       12 issues
   - MEDIUM:     11 issues
   - LOW:         5 issues

🟢 IMPROVEMENT:   15 issues

By Component

Backend:         25 issues
  - Scanner:      7 issues
  - Services:     6 issues
  - API:          8 issues
  - Database:     4 issues

Frontend:        18 issues
  - Types:        4 issues
  - Services:     6 issues
  - Components:   4 issues
  - Config:       4 issues

Infrastructure:  22 issues
  - Security:    12 issues
  - Database:     3 issues
  - Deployment:   4 issues
  - Testing:      3 issues

By Category

Type/Interface:  8 issues (frontend types don't match backend)
Database:        5 issues (sessions, migrations, backups)
Security:       12 issues (auth, rate limiting, headers)
Async/Concurrency: 6 issues (race conditions, deadlocks)
Error Handling:  8 issues (missing validation, edge cases)
Documentation:   5 issues (missing guides)
Testing:         5 issues (no comprehensive tests)
Configuration:   3 issues (hardcoded values)
Performance:     3 issues (scalability issues)

QUICK FIX ROADMAP

Phase 1: CRITICAL (2-3 hours)

These MUST be fixed for tool to work at all:

  1. ✅ Frontend npm install
  2. ✅ Frontend type definitions
  3. ✅ Database session handling
  4. ✅ WebSocket integration
  5. ✅ WebSocket thread safety
  6. ✅ Frontend env vars

Phase 2: HIGH (4-5 hours)

These should be fixed for reliable operation:

  1. Authentication/Authorization
  2. Rate limiting
  3. Input validation
  4. Error handling
  5. Security headers

Phase 3: MEDIUM (6-8 hours)

These improve production readiness:

  1. Database migration
  2. HTTPS/SSL
  3. Monitoring/logging
  4. Configuration management
  5. Backup strategy

Phase 4: LOW (10+ hours)

These improve quality:

  1. Comprehensive tests
  2. Performance optimization
  3. Documentation
  4. Deployment automation

FILE-BY-FILE IMPACT ANALYSIS

MUST MODIFY

backend:
  ✏️ app/api/endpoints/scans.py (high impact)
  ✏️ app/services/scan_service.py (high impact)
  ✏️ app/api/endpoints/websocket.py (high impact)
  ✏️ app/scanner/port_scanner.py (high impact)

frontend:
  ✏️ src/types/api.ts (CRITICAL - type safety)
  ✏️ .env (CRITICAL - connectivity)
  ✏️ src/services/api.ts (medium impact)
  ✏️ package.json (CRITICAL - dependencies)

SHOULD MODIFY

backend:
  ✏️ app/config.py (add security settings)
  ✏️ main.py (add middleware)
  ✏️ app/scanner/network_scanner.py (validation)
  ✏️ app/scanner/service_detector.py (error handling)

SHOULD CREATE

✨ frontend/.env (environment variables)
✨ frontend/.env.example (template)
✨ app/middleware/security.py (security headers)
✨ app/middleware/ratelimit.py (rate limiting)
✨ app/security/auth.py (authentication)

TESTING VALIDATION

After implementing fixes, verify with:

# Backend Tests
✅ Database initialization
✅ API starts without errors
✅ Scan can be started
✅ WebSocket connection established
✅ Real-time updates received
✅ Multiple concurrent scans work

# Frontend Tests
✅ npm install succeeds
✅ TypeScript compiles without errors
✅ npm run build completes
✅ Page loads in browser
✅ Can start scan from UI
✅ Real-time progress displayed
✅ Results render correctly

REFERENCE: Backend Models

Current Models

  • Scan: Scan operations
  • Host: Discovered hosts
  • Service: Open ports/services
  • Connection: Host relationships

Missing Models

  • User: Authentication
  • ScanTemplate: Saved scan configs
  • Notification: Alerts
  • Audit: Security logging

NOTES FOR DEVELOPER

  1. Database Session Pattern: Always create fresh sessions for background tasks
  2. WebSocket Design: Broadcast events from central manager
  3. Type Safety: Ensure frontend types match backend response schemas
  4. Async/Await: Be careful mixing sync/async code
  5. Error Messages: User-friendly, not technical dumps
  6. Security First: Validate all inputs, check permissions
  7. Logging: Log actions for security/debugging

Generated: December 4, 2025

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink