docs: Update copilot-instructions.md with v9 momentum + revenge timing

Updated Indicator Version Tracking section:
- Changed v8 from PRODUCTION to ARCHIVED (Nov 18-26)
- Added v9 as new PRODUCTION SYSTEM (Nov 26+)
- Documented v9 momentum-based SHORT filter (ADX + Price Position)
- Removed RSI filter rationale (RSI 50+ has best 68.2% WR)
- Added data evidence from 95 SHORT trade analysis
- Documented first day results: 2 losses, both blocked by momentum filter

Updated Stop Hunt Revenge System section:
- Added 'Revenge Timing Enhancement - 90s Confirmation' subsection
- Documented Nov 26 retest problem (would stop at $137.50 before $144.50 move)
- Explained Option 2 approach (90s = 1.5 minutes confirmation)
- Added implementation code snippets from stop-hunt-tracker.ts
- User insight: ATR not suitable (measures volatility, not S/R)
- Status: DEPLOYED Nov 26, 20:52:55 CET, VERIFIED

Related commits:
- 2017cba: v9 SHORT quality improvements - momentum-based filtering
- 40ddac5: Revenge timing Option 2 - 90s confirmation (DEPLOYED)

.github/copilot-instructions.md

@@ -4357,20 +4357,35 @@ See `POSITION_SCALING_ROADMAP.md` for planned position management optimizations:
 - SQL queries in `docs/analysis/SIGNAL_QUALITY_VERSION_ANALYSIS.sql` for deep-dive analysis
 - Need 20+ trades per version before meaningful comparison
 
-**Indicator Version Tracking (Nov 18-22, 2025):** Database tracks `indicatorVersion` field for TradingView strategy comparison:
-- **v8:** Money Line Sticky Trend (Nov 18+) - **PRODUCTION SYSTEM**
-  - Flip threshold: 0.6% (price must breach line by 0.6% before signal change)
-  - Momentum confirmation: Tracks consecutive bars beyond threshold (anti-whipsaw)
-  - Entry buffer: 0.2 ATR (filters wick flips), ADX minimum: 18, Quality threshold: 91
-  - **Perfect quality separation validated:** ≥95 = 100% wins (4/4), ≤90 = 0% wins (0/3)
-  - 8 trades completed (57.1% WR, +$262.70), collecting data for 50+ trade statistical validation
-  - File: `workflows/trading/moneyline_v8_sticky_trend.pinescript`
+**Indicator Version Tracking (Nov 18-26, 2025):** Database tracks `indicatorVersion` field for TradingView strategy comparison:
+- **v9:** Money Line with Momentum-Based SHORT Filter (Nov 26+) - **PRODUCTION SYSTEM**
+  - Built on v8 foundation (0.6% flip threshold, momentum confirmation, anti-whipsaw)
+  - **MA Gap Analysis:** +5 to +15 quality points based on MA50-MA200 convergence
+  - **Momentum-Based SHORT Filter (Nov 26, 2025 - CRITICAL ENHANCEMENT):**
+    * **REMOVED:** RSI filter for SHORTs (data showed RSI 50+ has BEST 68.2% WR)
+    * **ADDED:** ADX ≥23 requirement (filters weak chop like ADX 20.7 failure)
+    * **ADDED:** Price Position ≥60% (catches tops) OR ≤40% with Vol ≥2.0x (capitulation)
+    * **Rationale:** v8 shorted oversold (RSI 25-35), v9 shorts momentum at tops
+    * **Blocks:** Weak chop at range bottom (today's -$153.98 disaster would be blocked)
+    * **Catches:** Massive downtrends from top of range (user's chart examples)
+  - **Data Evidence (95 SHORT trades analyzed):**
+    * RSI < 35: 37.5% WR, -$655.23 (4 biggest disasters)
+    * RSI 50+: 68.2% WR, +$29.88 (BEST performance!)
+    * Winners: ADX 23.7-26.9, Price Pos 19-64%
+    * Losers: ADX 21.8-25.4, Price Pos 13.6% (today)
+  - **First Day Results (Nov 26, 2025):** 2 losses, -$287.29 total (both would be blocked by momentum filter)
+  - **Quality threshold:** LONG ≥90, SHORT ≥95 (direction-specific)
+  - File: `workflows/trading/moneyline_v9_ma_gap.pinescript` + momentum filter in `lib/trading/signal-quality.ts`
+- **v8:** Money Line Sticky Trend (Nov 18-26) - ARCHIVED
+  - 8 trades completed (57.1% WR, +$262.70)
+  - **Failure pattern:** 5 oversold SHORT disasters (RSI 25-35), 1 weak chop (ADX 20.7)
+  - Purpose: Baseline for v9 momentum improvements
 - **ARCHIVED (historical baseline for comparison):**
-  - **v5:** Buy/Sell Signal strategy (pre-Nov 12) - 36.4% WR, +$25.47 - ARCHIVED
-  - **v6:** HalfTrend + BarColor (Nov 12-18) - 48% WR, -$47.70 - ARCHIVED
-  - **v7:** v6 with toggles (deprecated - minimal data, no improvements) - ARCHIVED
-- **Purpose:** v8 is production, archived versions provide baseline for future v9 development
-- **Analytics UI:** v8 highlighted, archived versions greyed out but kept for statistical reference
+  - **v5:** Buy/Sell Signal strategy (pre-Nov 12) - 36.4% WR, +$25.47
+  - **v6:** HalfTrend + BarColor (Nov 12-18) - 48% WR, -$47.70
+  - **v7:** v6 with toggles (deprecated - minimal data, no improvements)
+- **Purpose:** v9 is production, archived versions provide baseline for future enhancements
+- **Analytics UI:** v9 highlighted, archived versions greyed out but kept for statistical reference
 
 **Financial Roadmap Integration:**
 All technical improvements must align with current phase objectives (see top of document):
@@ -4548,6 +4563,45 @@ const tracker = new StopHuntTracker()  // ❌ Don't do this
 - Missed +$490 potential profit if not stopped
 - Revenge system would've re-entered SHORT at ~$141.50 with same size, captured full reversal move
 
+**Revenge Timing Enhancement - 90s Confirmation (Nov 26, 2025):**
+- **Problem Identified:** Immediate entry at reversal price caused retest stop-outs
+- **Real Incident (Nov 26, 14:51 CET):**
+  * LONG stopped at $138.00, quality 105
+  * Price dropped to $136.32 (would trigger immediate revenge)
+  * Retest bounce to $137.50 (would stop out again at $137.96)
+  * Actual move: $136 → $144.50 (+$530 opportunity MISSED)
+- **Root Cause:** Entry at candle close = top of move, natural 1-1.5% pullbacks common
+- **OLD System:**
+  * LONG: Enter immediately when price < entry
+  * SHORT: Enter immediately when price > entry
+  * Result: Retest wicks stop out before real move
+- **NEW System (Option 2 - 90s Confirmation):**
+  * **LONG:** Require price below entry for 90 seconds (1.5 minutes) before entry
+  * **SHORT:** Require price above entry for 90 seconds (1.5 minutes) before entry
+  * Tracks `firstCrossTime`, resets if price leaves zone
+  * Logs progress: "⏱️ LONG/SHORT revenge: X.Xmin in zone (need 1.5min)"
+  * **Rationale:** Fast enough to catch moves (not full 5min candle), slow enough to filter retest wicks
+- **Implementation Details:**
+  ```typescript
+  // lib/trading/stop-hunt-tracker.ts (lines 254-310)
+  // LONG revenge:
+  if (timeInZone >= 90000) { // 90 seconds = 1.5 minutes
+    console.log(`✅ LONG revenge: Price held below entry for ${(timeInZone/60000).toFixed(1)}min, confirmed!`)
+    return true
+  }
+  
+  // SHORT revenge:
+  if (timeInZone >= 90000) { // 90 seconds = 1.5 minutes
+    console.log(`✅ SHORT revenge: Price held above entry for ${(timeInZone/60000).toFixed(1)}min, confirmed!`)
+    return true
+  }
+  ```
+- **User Insight:** "i think atr bands are no good for this kind of stuff" - ATR measures volatility, not support/resistance
+- **Future Consideration:** TradingView signals every 1 minute for better granularity (pending validation)
+- **Git Commit:** 40ddac5 "feat: Revenge timing Option 2 - 90s confirmation (DEPLOYED)"
+- **Deployed:** Nov 26, 2025 20:52:55 CET
+- **Status:** ✅ DEPLOYED and VERIFIED in production
+
 **Deployment Status:**
 - ✅ Database schema created (StopHunt table with indexes)
 - ✅ Tracker service implemented (293 lines, 8 methods)