Improved flip-flop penalty logic to distinguish between:
- Chop (bad): <2% price move from opposite signal → -25 penalty
- Reversal (good): ≥2% price move from opposite signal → allowed
Changes:
- lib/database/trades.ts: getRecentSignals() now returns oppositeDirectionPrice
- lib/trading/signal-quality.ts: Added currentPrice parameter, price movement check
- app/api/trading/check-risk/route.ts: Added currentPrice to RiskCheckRequest interface
- app/api/trading/execute/route.ts: Pass openResult.fillPrice as currentPrice
- app/api/analytics/reentry-check/route.ts: Pass currentPrice from metrics
Example scenarios:
- ETH $170 SHORT → $153 LONG (10% move) = reversal allowed ✅
- ETH $154.50 SHORT → $154.30 LONG (0.13% move) = chop blocked ⚠️
Deployed: 09:18 CET Nov 14, 2025
Container: trading-bot-v4
PHASE 1 IMPLEMENTATION:
Signal quality scoring now checks database for recent trading patterns
and applies penalties to prevent overtrading and flip-flop losses.
NEW PENALTIES:
1. Overtrading: 3+ signals in 30min → -20 points
- Detects consolidation zones where system generates excessive signals
- Counts both executed trades AND blocked signals
2. Flip-flop: Opposite direction in last 15min → -25 points
- Prevents rapid long→short→long whipsaws
- Example: SHORT at 10:00, LONG at 10:12 = blocked
3. Alternating pattern: Last 3 trades flip directions → -30 points
- Detects choppy market conditions
- Pattern like long→short→long = system getting chopped
DATABASE INTEGRATION:
- New function: getRecentSignals() in lib/database/trades.ts
- Queries last 30min of trades + blocked signals
- Checks last 3 executed trades for alternating pattern
- Zero performance impact (fast indexed queries)
ARCHITECTURE:
- scoreSignalQuality() now async (requires database access)
- All callers updated: check-risk, execute, reentry-check
- skipFrequencyCheck flag available for special cases
- Frequency penalties included in qualityResult breakdown
EXPECTED IMPACT:
- Eliminate overnight flip-flop losses (like SOL $141-145 chop)
- Reduce overtrading during sideways consolidation
- Better capital preservation in non-trending markets
- Should improve win rate by 5-10% by avoiding worst setups
TESTING:
- Deploy and monitor next 5 signals in choppy markets
- Check logs for frequency penalty messages
- Analyze if blocked signals would have been losers
Files changed:
- lib/database/trades.ts: Added getRecentSignals()
- lib/trading/signal-quality.ts: Made async, added frequency checks
- app/api/trading/check-risk/route.ts: await + symbol parameter
- app/api/trading/execute/route.ts: await + symbol parameter
- app/api/analytics/reentry-check/route.ts: await + skipFrequencyCheck
BUG FOUND:
Line 558: tp2SizePercent: config.takeProfit2SizePercent || 100
When config.takeProfit2SizePercent = 0 (TP2-as-runner system), JavaScript's ||
operator treats 0 as falsy and falls back to 100, causing TP2 to close 100%
of remaining position instead of activating trailing stop.
IMPACT:
- On-chain orders placed correctly (line 481 uses ?? correctly)
- Position Manager reads from DB and expects TP2 to close position
- Result: User sees TWO take-profit orders instead of runner system
FIX:
Changed both tp1SizePercent and tp2SizePercent to use ?? operator:
- tp1SizePercent: config.takeProfit1SizePercent ?? 75
- tp2SizePercent: config.takeProfit2SizePercent ?? 0
This allows 0 value to be saved correctly for TP2-as-runner system.
VERIFICATION NEEDED:
Current open SHORT position in database has tp2SizePercent=100 from before
this fix. Next trade will use correct runner system.
PROBLEM ANALYSIS:
Signal that lost -$32: ADX 14.8, VOL 2.29x → scored 70-90 (PASSED)
Signal that won +3%: ADX 15.7, VOL 1.18x → scored 45-65 (got BLOCKED before fix)
Key insight: High volume during choppy conditions (ADX < 16) indicates
whipsaw/trap, not genuine breakout. Our volume bonus (+15 pts for >1.5x)
was rewarding flip-flop signals instead of real moves.
FIX:
Add anti-chop filter in volume scoring:
- If ADX < 16 AND volume > 1.5x → -15 points (whipsaw trap)
- Overrides the normal +15 bonus for high volume
- Protects against false signals during consolidation
IMPACT ON RECENT SIGNALS:
1. 00:40 SHORT (ADX 17.2, VOL 0.98): 55→75 ✅ Still passes
2. 00:55 LONG (ADX 15, VOL 0.47): 35→55 ❌ Still blocked (correct, weak vol)
3. 01:05 SHORT (ADX 14.8, VOL 2.29): 70→60 ⚠️ Now flagged as whipsaw trap
4. 01:10 LONG (ADX 15.7, VOL 1.18): 45→65 ✅ Catches the +3% runup
Result: Loser signal now barely passes (60) with warning flag,
winner signal passes cleanly (65). Better risk/reward profile.
- Add market data cache service (5min expiry) for storing TradingView metrics
- Create /api/trading/market-data webhook endpoint for continuous data updates
- Add /api/analytics/reentry-check endpoint for validating manual trades
- Update execute endpoint to auto-cache metrics from incoming signals
- Enhance Telegram bot with pre-execution analytics validation
- Support --force flag to override analytics blocks
- Use fresh ADX/ATR/RSI data when available, fallback to historical
- Apply performance modifiers: -20 for losing streaks, +10 for winning
- Minimum re-entry score 55 (vs 60 for new signals)
- Fail-open design: proceeds if analytics unavailable
- Show data freshness and source in Telegram responses
- Add comprehensive setup guide in docs/guides/REENTRY_ANALYTICS_QUICKSTART.md
Phase 1 implementation for smart manual trade validation.
- Shorts/longs at < 15% range require ADX > 18 AND volume > 1.2x
- OR RSI < 35 for shorts, RSI > 60 for longs
- Increased penalty from -10 to -15 when conditions not met
- Changed threshold from < 5% to < 15% to catch more edge cases
Test results:
- Big loser (01:35): ADX 16.1, price 9.3% → Score 60 (was 90) → BLOCKED
- Today's signal (10:05): ADX 17.3, price 0.9% → Score 55 (was 85) → BLOCKED
Rationale: False breakdowns in choppy ranges (ADX < 18) cause losses.
Tradeoff: May block some profitable breakdowns, but prevents chop losses.
- Allow shorts at range bottom (<5%) with volume >1.2x OR RSI <40
- Allow longs at range bottom with volume >1.2x OR RSI >60
- Reduce ADX penalty from -15 to -5 when strong volume (>1.2x) present
- Reduce price position penalties from -15 to -10 (less harsh)
- Volume compensation recognizes breakdowns start before ADX strengthens
Test case (blocked signal that would have profited):
- OLD: ATR 0.32, ADX 17.3, RSI 32.5, Vol 1.27x, Price 0.9% → Score 45 (blocked)
- NEW: Same metrics → Score 85 (executes)
Rationale: Breakdowns continue lower, volume confirms conviction, ADX lags price action
